| Offense |
| Position |
Players |
| Quarterbacks |
Y. A. Tittle, New York
Bart Starr, Green Bay
|
| Running backs |
Jim Taylor, Green Bay
Don Perkins, Dallas
Dick Bass, Los Angeles
Jim Brown, Cleveland
John David Crow, St. Louis
John Henry Johnson, Pittsburgh
|
| Wide receivers |
Bobby Mitchell, Washington
Del Shofner, New York
Gail Cogdill, Detroit
Tommy McDonald, Philadelphia
Sonny Randle, St. Louis
|
| Tight ends |
Ron Kramer, Green Bay
Mike Ditka, Chicago
|
| Tackles |
Forrest Gregg, Green Bay
Rosey Brown, New York
Jack Stroud, New York
Mike McCormack, Cleveland
Bob St. Clair, San Francisco
|
| Guards |
Jerry Kramer, Green Bay
Jim Parker, Baltimore
Jim Ray Smith, Cleveland
Fuzzy Thurston, Green Bay
Harley Sewell, Detroit
Mike Sandusky, Pittsburgh
|
| Centers |
Jim Ringo, Green Bay
Ray Wietecha, New York
Buzz Nutter, Pittsburgh |
|
| Defense |
| Position |
Players |
| Defensive ends |
Gino Marchetti, Baltimore
Willie Davis, Green Bay
Jim Katcavage, New York
Doug Atkins, Chicago
Bill Glass, Cleveland
Andy Robustelli, New York
|
| Defensive tackles |
Roger Brown, Detroit
Henry Jordan, Green Bay
Alex Karras, Detroit
Bob Toneff, Washington
Bob Gain, Cleveland
Leo Nomellini, San Francisco
|
| Outside Linebackers |
Bill Forester, Green Bay
Dan Currie, Green Bay
Galen Fiss, Cleveland
Joe Fortunato, Chicago
Bill Pellington, Baltimore
|
| Inside Linebackers |
Joe Schmidt, Detroit
Matt Hazeltine, San Francisco
Ray Nitschke, Green Bay
|
| Cornerbacks |
Night Train Lane, Detroit
Herb Adderly, Green Bay
Abe Woodson, San Francisco
Erich Barnes, New York
Jimmy Hill, St. Louis
|
| Safety |
Yale Lary, Detroit
Jimmy Patton, New York
Willie Wood, Green Bay
Richie Petitbon, Chicago
Don Burroughs, Philadelphia
Clendon Thomas, Pittsburgh
|
|
|