| Contestant | Original Placement |
Episode | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | ||
| LaVita Chance | S5 - 6th | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | SAFE | WIN | WIN | BTM | WIN | BTM | HIGH | WIN | Winner |
| Casada Leon | S3 - 13th | HIGH | SAFE | WIN | WIN | SAFE | WIN | HIGH | LOW | WIN | LOW | BTM | Runner-up |
| Mariana Trench | S1 - 3rd | HIGH | SAFE | WIN | HIGH | SAFE | LOW | HIGH | HIGH | WIN | BTM | WIN | Eliminated |
| Primrose | S3 - 5th | WIN | SAFE | LOW | BTM | SAFE | ELIM | WIN | WIN | WIN | BTM | Eliminated | |
| Kharybdis | S4 - 3rd | BTM | WIN | SAFE | LOW | HIGH | SAFE | BTM | BTM | HIGH | WIN | ELIM | Guest |
| Cherry Bombshell | S3 - 2nd | LOW | HIGH | SAFE | HIGH | HIGH | SAFE | WIN | WIN | LOW | ELIM | Guest | |
| Olivia Face | S2 - 5th | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | BTM | BTM | SAFE | ELIM | Guest | ||
| Encore | S4 - 6th | SAFE | LOW | SAFE | SAFE | BTM | HIGH | WIN | ELIM | Guest | |||
| Kiki Bouba | S5 - 2nd | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | ELIM | OUT | Gold Star | |||
| Horina Toto | S1 - 10th | WIN | BTM | HIGH | WIN | ELIM | OUT | Guest | |||||
| Ida Ho | S5 - 10th | SAFE | BTM | BTM | ELIM | OUT | Guest | ||||||
| Ceres | S1 - 2nd | SAFE | HIGH | ELIM | OUT | Guest | |||||||
| Vanta Blaque | S2 - 6th | BTM | ELIM | OUT | Guest | ||||||||
| Lynda Hand | S3 - 7th | ELIM | OUT | Guest | |||||||||
| Episode | Challenge | Top All Stars (Elimination) |
Song | Winner(s) | Bottom | Eliminated | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | All Star Anthem | Horina Toto (Vanta) |
vs. | Primrose (Lynda) |
"Sunny" (Boney M.) |
Primrose | Kharybdis Lynda Hand Vanta Blaque |
Lynda Hand |
| 2 | RDR Live | Kharybdis (Vanta) |
vs. | Kiki Bouba (Vanta) |
"What Hurts the Most" (Cascada) |
Kiki | Horina Toto Ida Ho Vanta Blaque |
Vanta Blaque |
| 3 | The Four Ball | Casada Leon (Ceres) |
vs. | Mariana Trench (Ida) |
"Repeat" (David Guetta ft. Jessie J) |
Casada | Ceres Ida Ho |
Ceres |
| 4 | Miss Variety Show Extravaganza Pageant |
Casada Leon (Ida) |
vs. | Horina Toto (Primrose) |
"Do You Wanna Touch Me" (Joan Jett and the Blackhearts) |
Casada | Ida Ho Primrose |
Ida Ho |
| 5 | Snatch Game of Love | LaVita Chance (Horina) |
vs. | Olivia Face (Horina) |
"How Will I Know" (Whitney Houston) |
LaVita | Encore Horina Toto |
Horina Toto |
| Olivia | ||||||||
| 6 | RuDesigns | Casada Leon (Primrose) |
vs. | LaVita Chance (Primrose) |
"Sneakernight" (Vanessa Hudgens) |
LaVita | Olivia Face Primrose |
Primrose |
| 7 | Saturday Morning Wars | Cherry Bombshell (Kiki) |
vs. | Encore (Olivia) |
"Underappreciated" (Christina Aguilera) |
Cherry | Kharybdis Kiki Bouba Olivia Face |
Kiki Bouba |
| 8 | Revenge of the Queens Roast |
Primrose (Olivia) |
vs. | Vanta Blaque (Olivia) |
"Get Over You" (Sophie Ellis-Bextor) |
Primrose | Kharybdis Olivia Face |
Olivia Face |
| 9 | Rainbow: The Rusical | Casada Leon (Encore) vs. Mariana Trench (Encore) vs. Primrose (Encore) | "Everywhere" (Michelle Branch) |
Mariana | Encore LaVita Chance |
Encore | ||
| 10 | Me & Ru | Kharybdis (Cherry) |
vs. | Primrose (Mariana) |
"Play Your Part (Leading Role Mix)" (Deborah Cox) |
Mariana | Cherry Bombshell Mariana Trench |
Cherry Bombshell |
| 11 | All Star Makeovers | LaVita Chance (Kharybdis) |
vs. | Mariana Trench (Kharybdis) |
"Honey" (Robyn) |
Mariana | Casada Leon Mariana Trench Primrose |
Kharybdis |
| Episode | Final All Stars | Song | Winner | |||||
| 12 | Finale | Casada Leon | vs. | LaVita Chance | "Now That I Know" (Mariah Carey) |
LaVita Chance | ||