Cow-calf separation

☆ Save On Wikipedia ↗
Mother cow sniffing her calf before separation is fully completed

Cow-calf separation is the practice of separating calves from their mothers in the beef and dairy industries.[1] It is sometimes called dam-calf separation. It is near universal within the beef and dairy industries globally. It is usually done within hours or days in the dairy industry, which opinion polling found a majority of the public opposed when they became informed.[2][3] It is used in both conventional and organic production.[1]

Background

A dummy calf made of straw and calfskin, known as a "khal bacha," hung up on the wall of a dairy farm. When a young calf dies, it is not uncommon for dairy farmers in India to place the dead calf's stuffed body near the calf's mother, causing her to continue lactating.

Dairy cows are repeatedly impregnated to keep them producing milk.[4] This is because after pregnancy, milk production rates fall and lead to a dry period. This process is called the lactation cycle and usually lasts 305 days.[5] It is recommended to wait 45-60 days after a cow has calved before impregnating her again, allowing her body to recover.[6] Dairy cows typically give birth to around 2-3 calves in their life prior to slaughter at around 4-5 years old.[7][8] Cows that produce the most milk have the highest rate of infertility.[9] Although beef cattle are typically slaughtered around 12-24 months old, beef cows kept for breeding typically give birth to 8-12 calves and are slaughtered when they become infertile, which is at about 10 years old. In countries where it is illegal to slaughter cattle, such as India and Nepal, dairy cows that are no longer lactating are usually exported illegally or abandoned on the streets.[10][11] Calves in the beef industry are typically separated from their mothers at around 6-8 months old, whereas calves in the dairy industry are typically separated from their mothers within the first few days.[12] Beef cows produce a gallon of milk per day, whereas dairy cows produce six to eight gallons of milk per day.[13] Beef cows are allowed to stay with their herds and typically leave of their own accord within 24 hours before calving,[14] whereas dairy cows are separated from their herd about two months before calving.[15]

Newborn beef calves are temporarily separated from their mothers to perform procedures such as ear tagging,[16] whereas newborn dairy calves are separated from their mothers within hours or days and relocated to prevent the mother from developing maternal instinct, which is unneeded in cows that are not being used for breeding. Moreover, early separation allows dairy farmers to ensure that saleable milk gets sold while "waste milk", or milk that is unsuitable for human consumption, is used to feed the calf, thus maximizing profit.[1][17] Dairy bulls are seen as unprofitable since they don't produce milk and are a dairy breed. For efficiency, male dairy calves (along with some excess female dairy calves) are usually either sent for veal or killed on-farm within a few days of birth.[18] A handful are sold to a dairy bull semen company.[19] Male calves of beef breeds and dual-purpose breeds may be reared for beef instead. Calves raised for beef are weaned around seven months of age,[20] whereas calves raised for dairy or veal are weaned around eight weeks of age.[21][22] In countries where it is illegal to slaughter cattle, male calves are usually abandoned or starved to death.[11]

Effects

A newborn calf being force-fed colostrum.

Deviations from natural nursing behaviors are thought to have an impact on animal welfare. In nature, cows often start licking their calves on average 5-7 minutes after birth to remove the amniotic fluid and establish a bond. Around 90 minutes after birth, calves begin suckling. Calves naturally spend large amounts of time nearby their mother compared to other members of the herd and also mimic their mother's behaviors. Cows also often distance themselves and their calf from the rest of the adults in the herd for a few days after birth.[23] Calves tend to remain close to their mother until fully weaned at around 8-11 months old.[24] A 5-year study on social relationships within cattle find that they held stable attachments between mother and child for at least that time frame.[25] Calves in the beef industry are usually either moved from pasture to a feeding pen where their mothers cannot see, smell, or hear them, or placed into a pasture adjacent of their mother. Researchers believe the latter method reduces the stress caused by separation by allowing cows to socialize with their calves.[26]

Effects on mothers

Post separation, cows in the dairy industry have been reported to vocalize for a while.[4][27] Stress is higher,[28] activity levels increase, their calls become higher in pitch, and they stick their heads outside pens more frequently.[29] Cows also show reduced milk production after separation.[30]

Effects on calves

After separation, calves in the dairy industry are known to have increased vocalizations, weight loss or slow weight gain, and increased disease risk.[31] It also appears to lead to higher stress levels with higher catecholamine secretion.[28] The amount of contact or lack thereof with the mother influences calf development. Weight gain improves with at least 4 days of contact. Diarrhea reduces with at least 2 weeks of contact. Social competence improves with at least 12 weeks of contact.[32] Calves with longer contact with their mother also stand earlier post-birth.[33]

Calves in the dairy industry are often placed in individual housing such as calf hutches following their separation. This limits social behavior overall and leads to increased stress and fear.[32] Newborn calves in the dairy industry are sometimes force-fed colostrum through an esophageal tube,[34] which can be stressful and dangerous for the calf if not done properly.[35] Observations obtained at a calf research facility show that suckling a nipple bottle is about 35% faster than suckling the cow, and drinking milk from an open pail is about 85% faster than suckling a cow,[36] putting calves that have been separated from their mothers at higher risk of aspirating fluid that can lead to coughing and pneumonia.[37]

Early vs late separation

Researchers have found minimal contact is needed to make bonds. 5 minutes of maternal contact after birth with the calf is enough to result in a bond lasting 12 hours after separation.[38] Dairy farmers have often argued for doing separation early to minimize this bond. However, a 2019 review found the effects on behavior were worse with earlier separation. Another review found that changing the time of separation from 24 hours to 10 days did not consistently improve overall cow or calf health.[39] Weary and Chua found that cows vocalized more after separation from their calves at four days than at six hours or one day. Furthermore, increased vocalization when separated from their calves at four days post-partum is accompanied by an increase in the amount of visible eye-white displayed.[26]

In the rare dairy farming systems where cows are separated later and allowed to nurse pre-weaned calves, cows show signs of increased aversion to being milked. Researchers think they are trying to save milk for their calves.[40] "The first year was disastrous. We just couldn't get the cows away from the calves and into the milking parlour. For weeks we'd be dragging the cows in there," reports David Finley, of the Cream o' Galloway at Rainton Farm. "It took a long time for them to trust that the calves were still going to be there when they came back. It was so much stress as the cows just weren't used to it and didn't know what the rules were." Late separation has been found to reduce mortality rates in calves, help calves grow quicker, and reduce mastitis in cows. Finlay estimates that he has lost more than 2,000 litres of saleable milk to the calves, and believes this financial loss is the main reason why late separation is so rare. However, Finlay believes the late separation model is feasible and that the improvement in the health and immune systems of the young calves will yield long-term dividends that will compensate for the loss of milk.[41]

In the beef industry, early separation is defined as separating calves from their mothers at less than 180 days of age, with a range from as early as 45 days of age but averaging about 70–90 days of lactation. Early separation is most commonly practiced when feed is scarce or where breeding cows are at risk from reproductive failure because high nutrient requirements are not met. Early separation has resulted in heavier calves, which researchers interpret as better wellbeing. Cows are less stressed than calves, and behavioral changes induced by weaning are greater in multiparous than primiparous cows. When mutually strongly bonded cows and calves are separated early, cows search and call out for their calves between periods of energy-conserving depression.[26]

Controversy

The separation of newborn calves from their mothers in the dairy industry has faced criticism from members of the general public along with various animal rights and animal welfare groups. For instance, Animal Equality has called it "cruel", "unnatural", and "painful".[42] Animal Justice has called it "some of the worst cruelty in the dairy industry" and called to end its use.[43] Separation of calves from their mothers in the beef industry is notably less controversial than in the dairy industry, due to the timing being closer to when they would naturally wean in the wild.[44]

Opinion polling found much of the public was unaware of the practice; but when informed, a majority were against it. Providing more information and arguments in favor tended not to change the level of disapproval.[2][45] Moreover, some researchers have found bringing people unaffiliated with the industry to a dairy farm caused a net loss of confidence in the industries' animal welfare, in part due to unawareness of early cow-calf separation.[2]

Those within the dairy industry have offered different justifications for maintaining early cow-calf separation. Decreasing the cost of operations is a commonly cited reason.[46] Also often cited is the physical safety of calves as a reason for separation. Though others argue this is more an issue with the existing housing rather than with keeping calves and mothers together.[47] Another reason cited by the industry has been to separate to reduce disease risk to calves. Researchers do not find consistent support for this claim.[47][39] Some farmers have claimed that increased time between calves and mothers makes them behave more "wild" and difficult to manage. Other farmers have stated the opposite experience and claimed they are calmer.[48]

See also

References

  1. Placzek, M.; Christoph-Schulz, I.; Barth, K. (March 2021). "Public attitude towards cow-calf separation and other common practices of calf rearing in dairy farming—a review". Organic Agriculture. 11 (1): 41–50. Bibcode:2021OrgAg..11...41P. doi:10.1007/s13165-020-00321-3. ISSN 1879-4238.
  2. Hötzel, Maria J.; Cardoso, Clarissa S.; Roslindo, Angélica; von Keyserlingk, Marina A.G. (May 2017). "Citizens' views on the practices of zero-grazing and cow-calf separation in the dairy industry: Does providing information increase acceptability?". Journal of Dairy Science. 100 (5): 4150–4160. doi:10.3168/jds.2016-11933. PMID 28259414.
  3. Meagher, Rebecca K.; Beaver, Annabelle; Weary, Daniel M.; von Keyserlingk, Marina A.G. (July 2019). "Invited review: A systematic review of the effects of prolonged cow–calf contact on behavior, welfare, and productivity". Journal of Dairy Science. 102 (7): 5765–5783. doi:10.3168/jds.2018-16021. PMID 31103300.
  4. Bolotnikova, Marina (2025-04-03). "The life of a dairy cow". Vox. Retrieved 2025-08-04.
  5. Erickson, Peter S.; Kalscheur, Kenneth F. (2020). "Nutrition and feeding of dairy cattle". Animal Agriculture. Elsevier. pp. 157–180. doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-817052-6.00009-4. ISBN 978-0-12-817052-6. PMC 7153313.
  6. "Is There an Ideal Voluntary Waiting Period for Inseminating Your Dairy Cows?". South Dakota State University. 2023-05-23. Retrieved 2026-01-18.
  7. Jacobs, Andrew (2020-12-29). "Is Dairy Farming Cruel to Cows? (Published 2020)". The New York Times. Retrieved 2025-08-04. The typical dairy cow in the United States will spend its entire life inside a concrete-floored enclosure, and although they can live 20 years, most are sent to slaughter after four or five years when their milk production wanes.
  8. "Life Cycle of a Dairy Cow: How Many Years Do Cows Live?". 2022-03-04. Retrieved 2025-08-04. Cows in the dairy industry typically give birth two or three times before they are slaughtered
  9. M C, Lucy (June 2001). "Reproductive loss in high-producing dairy cattle: where will it end?". Journal of Dairy Science. 84 (6): 1277–93. doi:10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(01)70158-0. ISSN 2573-2196. PMID 11417685.
  10. Buncombe, Andrew (June 2012). "Nothing's sacred: the illegal trade in India's holy cows". The Independent. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  11. Pathak, Sushmita (31 March 2023). "India's 5 million stray cows are sacred — and a growing nuisance". National Geographic. Retrieved 1 June 2026.
  12. Lidfors, Lena (2022). "Parental Behavior in Bovines". Advances in Neurobiology. 27: 177–212. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-97762-7_6. ISBN 978-3-030-97761-0. PMID 36169816.
  13. Mayer, Melissa (29 January 2026). "Why do dairy cows produce so much milk compared to beef cows?". Ask Dr. Universe. Washington State University. Retrieved 9 May 2026.
  14. Scott, Phil. "Calving Part 1 The Basics". NADIS. National Animal Disease Information Service. Retrieved 26 May 2026.
  15. "The life of: dairy cows" (PDF). CIWF. Compassion in World Farming. Retrieved 26 May 2026.
  16. "Working Cattle With Safety in Mind" (PDF). University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture. pp. 1–3. Archived (PDF) from the original on 5 June 2024. Retrieved 3 December 2025.
  17. Ma, Y; Khan, MZ; Alugongo, GM; Chen, X; Li, S; Wang, Y; Cao, Z (May 17, 2022). "An Overview of Waste Milk Feeding Effect on Growth Performance, Metabolism, Antioxidant Status and Immunity of Dairy Calves". Frontiers in Veterinary Science. 9 (898295) 898295. doi:10.3389/fvets.2022.898295. PMC 9152456. PMID 35656173.
  18. Reed, Lexie M.; Renaud, David L.; DeVries, Trevor J. (February 2022). "Male dairy calf welfare: A Canadian perspective on challenges and potential solutions". The Canadian Veterinary Journal. 63 (2): 187–193. ISSN 0008-5286. PMC 8759333. PMID 35110777.
  19. "Dairy farmers drive bull market in cattle semen". 2020-12-29. Retrieved 2026-01-19.
  20. Karisch, Brandi; Parish, Jane. "Early Weaning Beef Calves". Mississippi State University Extension Service. Mississippi State University. Retrieved 9 May 2026.
  21. "Life Cycle of Dairy Cattle". Oklahoma State University. Ferguson Family Dairy Center. 6 July 2022. Retrieved 9 May 2026.
  22. Campbell, Andrew (18 May 2021). "Learn more about Raising Veal Cattle". Canadian Food Focus. Sustainable Canadian Agriculture Partnership. Retrieved 9 May 2026.
  23. Whalin, Laura; Weary, Daniel M.; von Keyserlingk, Marina A. G. (2021-08-20). "Understanding Behavioural Development of Calves in Natural Settings to Inform Calf Management". Animals. 11 (8): 2446. doi:10.3390/ani11082446. ISSN 2076-2615. PMC 8388734. PMID 34438903.
  24. Johnsen, Julie Føske; Ellingsen, Kristian; Grøndahl, Ann Margaret; Bøe, Knut Egil; Lidfors, Lena; Mejdell, Cecilie Marie (2015-05-01). "The effect of physical contact between dairy cows and calves during separation on their post-separation behavioural response". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 166: 11–19. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2015.03.002. ISSN 0168-1591.
  25. Reinhardt, Viktor; Reinhardt, Annie (1981). "Cohesive Relationships in a Cattle Herd (Bos Indicus)". Behaviour. 77 (3): 121–150. Bibcode:1981Behav..77..121R. doi:10.1163/156853981X00194. ISSN 0005-7959.
  26. Orihuela, Agustín; Galina, Carlos S. (8 May 2019). "Effects of Separation of Cows and Calves on Reproductive Performance and Animal Welfare in Tropical Beef Cattle". Impact of Environment and Stressors on Animal Welfare. 9 (5): 223. doi:10.3390/ani9050223. PMC 6562594. PMID 31071919. This article incorporates text from this source, which is available under the CC BY 4.0 license.
  27. Sirovnik, Janja; Simon, Rebecca; Vogt, Anina; Barth, Kerstin; Smith, Steve; Waiblinger, Susanne; Lühken, Gesine; König von Borstel, Uta (2025-03-17). Abuelo, Angel (ed.). "Relative telomere length in dairy calves and dams undergoing two different methods of weaning and separation after three months of contact". PLOS ONE. 20 (3) e0319156. Bibcode:2025PLoSO..2019156S. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0319156. ISSN 1932-6203. PMC 11913301. PMID 40096055.
  28. Marchant, Jeremy N.; Marchant-Forde, Ruth M.; Weary, Daniel M. (Aug 2002). "Responses of dairy cows and calves to each other's vocalisations after early separation". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 78 (1): 19–28. doi:10.1016/S0168-1591(02)00082-5.
  29. Stěhulová, Ilona; Lidfors, Lena; Špinka, Marek (Mar 2008). "Response of dairy cows and calves to early separation: Effect of calf age and visual and auditory contact after separation". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 110 (1–2): 144–165. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2007.03.028.
  30. Sandem, Agnethe-Irén; Braastad, Bjarne O. (2005-12-01). "Effects of cow–calf separation on visible eye white and behaviour in dairy cows—A brief report". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 95 (3): 233–239. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2005.04.011. ISSN 0168-1591.
  31. Weary, Daniel M.; Chua, Beverly (September 2000). "Effects of early separation on the dairy cow and calf". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 69 (3): 177–188. Bibcode:2000AABS...69..177W. doi:10.1016/S0168-1591(00)00128-3. PMID 10906402.
  32. EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Animal Welfare (AHAW); Nielsen, Søren Saxmose; Alvarez, Julio; Bicout, Dominique Joseph; Calistri, Paolo; Canali, Elisabetta; Drewe, Julian Ashley; Garin-Bastuji, Bruno; Gonzales Rojas, Jose Luis; Gortazar Schmidt, Christian; Herskin, Mette; Michel, Virginie; Miranda Chueca, Miguel Angel; Padalino, Barbara; Pasquali, Paolo (Mar 2023). "Welfare of calves". EFSA Journal. 21 (3): e07896. doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2023.7896. PMC 10050971. PMID 37009444.
  33. Johnsen, Julie Føske; de Passille, Anne Marie; Mejdell, Cecilie Marie; Bøe, Knut Egil; Grøndahl, Ann Margaret; Beaver, Annabelle; Rushen, Jeffrey; Weary, Daniel M. (2015-02-01). "The effect of nursing on the cow–calf bond". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 163: 50–57. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2014.12.003. ISSN 0168-1591.
  34. Jones, Coleen M.; Heinrichs, Jud Marie (6 October 2025). "Feeding the Newborn Dairy Calf". PETA. Retrieved 12 October 2024. Newborn calves are sometimes too weak to suckle or nurse from a pail or bottle. The esophageal feeder is an excellent device for force-feeding colostrum to these calves or for feeding electrolytes to sick calves. This inexpensive piece of equipment can save the life of a sick or weak calf.
  35. Shoof International Ltd. (6 October 2025). "Tube Feeding Designed by a Vet – Chosen by Farmers – Preferred by Calves". SHOOF. Retrieved 13 May 2026.
  36. Costello, Rob (10 August 2017). "Calf Feeding – Bottles vs. Pails". Calf Sessions. Retrieved 13 May 2026.
  37. Sprouse, Vickie (17 May 2022). "Buckets or Bottles – The Pros and Cons of Both". Strauss Feeds. Retrieved 13 May 2026.
  38. von Keyserlingk, Marina A.G.; Weary, Daniel M. (June 2007). "Maternal behavior in cattle". Hormones and Behavior. 52 (1): 106–113. doi:10.1016/j.yhbeh.2007.03.015. PMID 17490663.
  39. Roadknight, Natalie; Wales, William; Jongman, Ellen; Mansell, Peter; Hepworth, Graham; Fisher, Andrew (April 2022). "Does the duration of repeated temporary separation affect welfare in dairy cow-calf contact systems?". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 249 105592. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2022.105592.
  40. Johnsen, Julie Føske; Zipp, Katharina A.; Kälber, Tasja; Passillé, Anne Marie de; Knierim, Ute; Barth, Kerstin; Mejdell, Cecilie Marie (September 2016). "Is rearing calves with the dam a feasible option for dairy farms?—Current and future research". Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 181: 1–11. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2015.11.011.
  41. Levitt, Tom (29 June 2019). "Rise of ethical milk: 'Mums ask when cows and their calves are separated'". The Guardian. Retrieved 20 June 2026.
  42. Equality, Animal (2022-10-14). "9 cruel yet legal farming practices". Animal Equality. Retrieved 2025-08-08.
  43. Nickerson, Shannon (2022-01-20). "End Cow & Calf Separation in NFACC Dairy Code". Animal Justice. Retrieved 2025-08-08.
  44. "Calves are separated from their mothers at birth: True or False?". La chaire bien-être animal. 13 May 2024. Retrieved 25 May 2026.
  45. Busch, Gesa; Weary, Daniel M.; Spiller, Achim; von Keyserlingk, Marina A. G. (2017-03-16). Olsson, I Anna S (ed.). "American and German attitudes towards cow-calf separation on dairy farms". PLOS ONE. 12 (3) e0174013. Bibcode:2017PLoSO..1274013B. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0174013. ISSN 1932-6203. PMC 5354428. PMID 28301604.
  46. Johanssen, Juni Rosann E.; Kvam, Gunn-Turid; Logstein, Brit; Vaarst, Mette (2023-09-01). "Interrelationships between cows, calves, and humans in cow-calf contact systems—An interview study among Norwegian dairy farmers". Journal of Dairy Science. 106 (9): 6325–6341. doi:10.3168/jds.2022-22999. ISSN 0022-0302. PMID 37419741.
  47. Sirovica, Lara (2021). Public perceptions of dairy cow-calf management systems differing in type of social and maternal contact (Master of Science thesis). University of British Colombia.
  48. Vaarst, Mette; Hellec, Florence; Verwer, Cynthia; Johanssen, Juni Rosann E.; Sørheim, Kristin (2020). "Cow calf contact in dairy herds viewed from the perspectives of calves, cows, humans and the farming system. Farmers' perceptions and experiences related to dam-rearing systems". Landbauforschung. 70 (1): 49–57. doi:10.3220/LBF1596195636000. ISSN 2194-3605.