
This is a list of the various polities that existed during the Shang dynasty in ancient China, attested in oracle bones, bronze inscriptions, and the Chinese classics.
Background

The Shang dynasty was the earliest archaeologically attested dynasty of China, dating back to around 1,600 BCE. During this time, numerous polities coexisted with the Shang people, including Predynastic Zhou, all of which had differing relations with them at different times. The Shang called differing polities fang (方), which in Modern Standard Chinese means "place."[1] The names for these polities comes from the Chinese classics (e.g. Records of the Grand Historian) written after the Shang dynasty was defeated at the Battle of Muye, Shang-Zhou dynasty ritual bronzes, and oracle bones unearthed at Yinxu and other sites. The latter two were written in bronze script and oracle bone script, respectively, which are ancient versions of the modern Han script used to write Chinese. Therefore, some names may not be stable.[1] In oracle bone inscriptions, different polities were often referred to as name + "方", from which contemporary state names are derived.[2] Modern scholarship often refers to these polities as fangguo (方國), translating to “fang polities” or “regional states,” though the precise status of each named group is debated.
Identifying Fang states
While formulaic, the grammar and handwriting seen in bronze and oracle bone inscriptions is not always straightforward, and conflicting interpretations may lead to difficulties in conclusively verifying a Fang polity's existence. Tang Yingjie gives eight criteria that can be used to identify them in different settings:[3]
- It is called X方 in oracle bone inscriptions.
- It is called 侯 or 伯 in oracle bones or bronze inscriptions.
- It appears as X in the phrase X王 in oracle bones.
- A small number of cases called 子 may count.
- It fought a large-scale war with the Shang royal house (e.g. Verbs for invasion, such as wang 往 or fa 伐, are used.
- Archaeological materials prove it was a Fang polity.
- Transmitted texts mention it, and that record is corroborated by oracle bones, bronze inscriptions, or archaeology.
- The “nine bang” 九邦 in the Shanghai Museum bamboo-slip text 《容成氏》 are included.
List of Fangs
The Latin names of Fangs are pronounced according to the Pinyin system established by the People's Republic of China in 1958, which is different from their ancient pronunciations in Old Chinese given the thousands of years of language change.
| Romanized name | Chinese name | Period of existence | Rough geographical location | Relationship with the Shang dynasty | Attested in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shang | 商方 | Xia dynasty,[a] Shang dynasty | Yinxu (大邑商 "Da Yi Shang", "Shang, the Great City") (present Anyang)[1] | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Oracle bones Ritual bronzes[5] | |
| Zifang | 子方 | Shang dynasty | ally?[b] | Oracle bones[6] | |
| Tufang | 土方 | Early to middle Shang dynasty, conquered by Wu Ding | Northwest of Yin, east of Hong Fang (present Fen River Basin, Shanxi Province) | enemy | Book of Poetry (Chang Fa (長發)[7] Oracle bones[8][9] |
| Gongfang | 𢀛方 | Shang dynasty, to period of Zu Geng | Northwest of Yin, west of Tu Fang (north of present Shaanxi Province, Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | swing | Oracle bones[10][11][12] |
| Guifang | 鬼方 | Shang dynasty | Northwest of Yin (present central Shanxi Province and northern Shaanxi province, Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | ally | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Bamboo Annals[13] |
| Qiang | 羌方 | Shang dynasty | Northwest of Yin (present Shaanxi Province, the area around Gansu Province, Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Book of Poetry[7] Oracle bones[14] |
| Northern Qiang | 北羌 | Shang dynasty | Northwest of Yin, north of Qiangfang | swing | Oracle bones[15] |
| Renfang[c] | 人方 | Shang dynasty | Southeast of Yin, coast of the Donghai (present Huai River basin and coast of the Yellow Sea at the Shandong Peninsula, northern Anhui and southern Shandong)) | enemy | Oracle bones[16] |
| Zhou[d] | 周方 | Middle to late Shang dynasty, overthrew Di Xin and established the Zhou dynasty. | West of Yin (present Qishan County) | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4] |
| Dapeng | 大彭 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Tongshan) | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Bamboo Annals Oracle bones[18][19] |
| Tangfang | 唐方 | Shang dynasty | Northwest of Yin | ||
| Jingfang | 井方 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin[20] | ally | Oracle bones[20] |
| Linfang | 林方 | Shang dynasty | South of Mount Tai and north of Wen River[21] | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4] |
| Xingfang | 興方 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | swing | Oracle bones[22] |
| Mafang | 馬方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Shilou County) | enemy | Possibly in bronze inscriptions (e.g. Ma gui (馬簋).[23] |
| Shifang | 豕方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Weifang or Xiawei | 危方 or 下危 | Shang dynasty | enemy, later conquered | Oracle bones[24] | |
| Yufang | 盂方 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | Oracle bones[21][25][26] | |
| Zhifang | 沚方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau); arguments are made for the east. | swing | Oracle bones[27] |
| Pangfang | 旁方 | Shang dynasty | swing | Oracle bones[28] | |
| Gefang | 戈方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present south of Shanxi Province) | ally | Oracle bones[29] |
| Mufang | 木方 | Shang dynasty | Bronze inscriptions[30] Oracle bones[31] | ||
| Bafang | 巴方 | Xia dynasty, Shang dynasty | Sichuan Province, also argued to be to be southern Shaanxi or Jianghan | enemy | Bamboo Annals[13] Oracle bones[32][33] |
| Shu | 蜀 | Shang dynasty | Sichuan Province | enemy | Bamboo Annals[13] Oracle bones[34] |
| Genfang | 亙方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | enemy, suppressed | Oracle bones[35] |
| Longfang | 龍方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau); arguments are made for an eastern location. | swing | Oracle bones[27] |
| Jifang | 基方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Puxian) | enemy | Oracle bones[36][37] |
| Jianfang | 湔方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | enemy | Oracle bones[36] |
| Jifang | 祭方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin, between Shang and Zhou | swing | Oracle bones[5][35] |
| Shifang | 示方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Maofang | 髳方 | Shang dynasty | enemy | Bamboo Annals[13][35] | |
| Zhaofang | 召方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | enemy | Oracle bones[3] |
| Yinfang | 印方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Hufang | 虎方 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Bronze inscriptions[3] |
| Weifang | 微方 | Shang dynasty | Bamboo Annals[13] Oracle bones[38] | ||
| Xifang | 息方 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin (Luoshan County) | ally | Oracle bones[39][40] |
| Miefang | 眣方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Zhifang | 止方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Yinfang | 尹方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Bufang | 步方 | Shang dynasty | Oracle bones[41] | ||
| Guifang | 歸方 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin (present Zigui) | enemy | Oracle bones?[42] |
| Zengfang | 曾方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Zhufang | 祝方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Nongfang | 弄方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Chuifang | 吹方 | Shang dynasty | Oracle bones[43] | ||
| Chefang | 屮方 (艸方?) | Shang dynasty | |||
| Yuejifang | 月丮方 | Shang dynasty | |||
| Chengefang? | 10px方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin, Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau | enemy | |
| Shang dynasty | ally | ||||
| Jifang | 㠱方 | Shang dynasty | North of Yin (present Beijing and northeastern Hebei, to the west of Liaoning) | ally | Oracle bones?[44] |
| Shang dynasty | |||||
| Shang dynasty | |||||
| Shang dynasty | |||||
| Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | swing | |||
| Shang dynasty | |||||
| Gu | 雇 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin (present southwest of Yuanyang County, northwest of Yuanwu Town, Henan Province) | ally | Oracle bones[3] |
| Bao | 暴 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin (present Yuanyang County) | ally | Oracle bones through a Marquess name[45] |
| Lu | 盧 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin (present Zhushan County and Ankang City) | enemy | Oracle bones[3] [46] |
| Shi | 矢方 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | enemy | |
| You | 攸 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present southern part of Yongcheng City and northwestern part of Suzhou City) | ally | Oracle bones[45] |
| Yuan | 元 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Yongcheng City) | ally | |
| Jifang | 及 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Yongcheng City) | ally | |
| Shen | 侁 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Cao County) | ||
| Gao | 告 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Chengwu County) | ally | |
| Dun | 盾 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | ally | |
| Tui | 魋 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | enemy | |
| Yachou | 亞醜 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Qingzhou, Shandong) | ally | Bronze inscriptions[47] |
| Jifang | 紀 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Shouguang) | ||
| Xue or Pi | 薛 or 邳 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin (present Tengzhou) | ally | Records of the Grand Historian[4] Bronze inscriptions[48][49] |
| Feng | 豐 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | swing | |
| Pang | 逢 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | ally | |
| Bogu | 薄姑 | Shang dynasty | East of Yin | ally | Bamboo Annals[13] |
| Yufang | 鬱方 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | ally | Oracle bones?[5] |
| Xuanfang | 宣方 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | ally | Oracle bones?[5] |
| Xiufang | 羞方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | swing | Oracle bones[50] |
| Songfang | 宋方 | Shang dynasty | North of Yin (present Zhao County) | ally | Oracle bones as an Earl[51][52] |
| Beifang | 貝方 | Shang dynasty | South of Yin | ||
| Cangfang | 倉方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Shangzhou District) | ally | Oracle bones[53] |
| Quanfang | 犬方[e] | Shang dynasty | West of Yin | swing | Oracle bones[54] |
| Yangfang | 昜方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Hongdong) | ||
| Foufang | 缶方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin | Oracle bones[55][10] | |
| Danfang | 丹方 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Qinyang) | ally | Oracle bones[56] |
| Qu | 去 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin | ally | |
| Shangsi | 上絲 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin | ally | |
| Hefang | 禾 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin | ||
| Guang | 光 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin, in modern-day Guang County, Henan | ally | Oracle bones[57] |
| Ke | 可 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Xiuwu County) | ally | |
| Er | 耳 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | swing | |
| Lü | 呂 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (Northern Shanxi-Shaanxi Plateau) | enemy | [58] |
| Bing | 丙 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Lingshi) | ||
| Xian | 先 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Fushan) | ||
| Na | 郍 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Xinzheng, Zhengzhou, Henan Province) | ||
| Lu | 鹿 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Song County) | swing | Bamboo Annals[13] |
| Qi | 耆 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Licheng) | swing | |
| Chong | 崇,琮,虫 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Xi'an) | swing | Records of the Grand Historian[4][59][60][61] |
| Mixu | 密須 | Shang dynasty | West of Yin (present Lingtai) | swing | Bamboo Annals[13] |
| Jian | 戔 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | ally | |
| Ban | 班 | Shang dynasty | Unknown | ally? | Bamboo Annals[13] |
| Gufang | 榖方 | Shang dynasty | ally | Oracle bones[62] |
See also
Notes
- The existence of the Xia dynasty is disputed due to a lack of testable evidence.
- Thought to be related to the Zi surname held by the Shang royal family
- Often identified as the Dongyi.
- Identification of the Zhoufang as the Predynastic Zhou is disputed.[17]
- Often attested as 犬侯 and sometimes argued to be the Rong
References
- Wilkinson, Endymion (2025). Chinese History: A New Manual. Pleco. ISBN 978-0-9988883-2-3.
- D. Howard Smith (1961). "Chinese Religion in the Shang Dynasty". Numen. 8: 142–150. doi:10.1163/156852761X00090.
- Tang Yingjie 唐英傑. 2021. 商代甲骨文地名統計與地望研究. 西南大學博士學位論文. Doctoral dissertation. Available at: https://lib.swu.edu.cn/uploads/2021-06-04/140885544d304751bf87afba64c27bbf.pdf
- Sima, Qian. "殷本紀,周本紀". In Sturgeon, Donald (ed.). 史記 (in Literary Chinese). Chinese Text Project.
- Sun 孙, Yabing 亚冰; Lin 林, Huan 欢 (2010). 商代地理与方国. 中国社会科学出版社. ISBN 978-7-5004-8924-5.
- Qiu 裘, Xigui 錫圭 (2008). "說殷墟卜辭的"奠" ——試論商人處置服屬者的一種方法". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心 (in Chinese).
- Sturgeon, Donald (ed.). 詩經 (in Literary Chinese). Chinese Text Project.
- 甲骨文合集00559正.5:戊辰卜𬆩貞王循土方
- 甲骨文合集06446正:貞勿惟土方征
- Zhang 張, Yuwei 張宇衛 (1 December 2019). "甲骨卜辭「X受Y又(祐)」意義及其相關問題再探". 國文學報 (66). doi:10.6239/BOC.201912_(66).06. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Wu 吴, Shengya 盛亚 (2018). "卜辞 "允" 字用法补说" [A research on the usage of yun(允) in the Oracle Bone Inscriptions]. Journal of Chinese Writing Systems (in Chinese). 2 (4). doi:10.1177/251385021876599. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Li 李, Fa 發 (2010). "有關商與𢀛方關係的甲骨刻辭之整理與研究". 語言文字與文學詮釋國際學術研討會.
- Donald Sturgeon (ed.). 竹書紀年. Chinese Text Project.
- Nicola Di Cosmo (13 March 1999). "The Northern Frontier in Pre-Imperial China". In Michael Loewe, Edward L. Shaughness (ed.). The Cambridge History of Ancient China: From the Origins of Civilization to 221 B.C. Cambridge University Press. p. 908. ISBN 0-521-47030-7.
- Zhu 朱, Wangming 望明 (2016). "漢代羌人的社會政治組織與族群認同". 歷史人類學學刊. 14 (1). Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Sun 孫, Ming 明 (2017). "商代"賈"銘諸器及相關問題探討". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心.
- Dong 董, Shan 珊 (2009). "试论殷墟卜辞之"周"为金文中的妘姓之琱". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Wu, Hung (1990). "The Art of Xuzhou: A Regional Approach" (PDF). Orientations. 21. Hong Kong: 40–59. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-08-29. Retrieved 2016-02-10.
- Higham, Charles (2004). Encyclopedia of Ancient Asian Civilizations. New York City: Infobase Publishing. ISBN 0-8160-4640-9.
- Chen 陈, Jie 絜; Tang 唐, Li 立 (2025). "地理基础与研究路径:观察商代文明的新窗口". 光明日报. 10. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Chen 陈, Jie 絜 (2022). "试说商末征人方路线中的 几个未释地名" (PDF). 故宮博物院院刊. 9.
- Zhu 朱, Qixiang 歧祥 (2008). "尋「丁」記-論非王卜辭中的武丁" (PDF). 東海中文學報. 20: 1-8.
- Wei 魏, Jianzhen 建震 (2004). "2003年先秦史研究动态". 中国史研究动态. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Xiu 裘, Xigui 錫圭 (2008). "說殷墟卜辭的"奠" ——試論商人處置服屬者的一種方法". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Tang 唐, Yingjie 英傑 (2016). "也說甲骨卜辭中的"【今口卜】巫九【夂口卜】". 第六屆出土文獻研究與比較文字學全國博士論壇. 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 方 Fang, Zhisong 稚松 (2019). "小臣墙骨版刻辞残缺文字拟补" (PDF). 故宮博物院院刊. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Chen 陈, Jie 絜 (2021). ""伯或征卲"与晚商沚族 * ——兼论卜辞地名地理研究在古文字考释中的辅助作用" (PDF). 故宮博物院院刊. 4. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 旁 in 漢語多功能字庫, The Chinese University of Hong Kong. 2026. https://humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=%E6%97%81
- Jin 靳, Yinduo 银豆 (2022). "殷商时期泾水流域的古族古国研究". Entrepreneurship and Innovation. 6 (3). doi:10.12184/wspcyycxWSP2516-413909.20220603. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Li 李, Weiming 维明 (2012). "郑州商文化陶字符量化分析" (PDF). 南方文物. 3: 38-45. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 合集 Heji 33193
- Zhao 趙, Lin 林 (1 April 2008). "商王武丁伐巴方". 中國文化大學中文學報 (16). doi:10.29989/ZGWHDXZWXB.200804.0002. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- Sage, Steven F. (1992). Ancient Sichuan and the unification of China. Albany: State University of New York Press. ISBN 978-0791410387.
- Kleeman, Terry F. (1998). Ta Chʻeng, Great Perfection – Religion and Ethnicity in a Chinese Millennial Kingdom. Honolulu: University of Hawaiʻi Press. ISBN 0-8248-1800-8.
- Luo 罗, Kun 琨 (2006). "商代亘方考" (PDF). 二十一世纪中国考古学——庆祝佟柱臣先生八十五华诞学术论文集.
- Zhang 張, Weijie 惟捷 (2014). "殷商武丁時期人物「雀」史跡研究" (PDF). 中央研究院歷史語言研究所集刊. 85 (4).
- Jian 錢, Weizhen 唯真 (2019). "論甲骨文字形與字詞義之關係─以面容器官類字詞為例". 第二十一屆中區文字學學術研討會論文集.
- Kim, Jeong-yeol (February 2020). "Disintegration and Reorganization of Shang yimin 商遺民 (the People of the Former Shang Dynasty) Considered Through the Unearthed Materials — Focused on the Core Areas in the Western Zhou —". Historical Studies of Ancient and Medieval China (55): 1–45. doi:10.15840/amch.2020..55.001. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 王長丰, 〈“息”方國族氏考〉, 《中原文物》2007年第2期, pp. 59–65
- 闫孟莲. 息国历史与地理论考[J]. 信阳师范学院学报(哲学社会科学版), 2010, 30(1): 93-96. DOI: 1003-0964(2010)01-0093-04. Available at: http://xb.xynu.edu.cn/article/id/e9180d18-0aa0-4f0d-ab74-1bc02ea52b1a
- Zhang 张, Yujin 玉金 (2021). "殷墟甲骨文"步"字意义新探". 出土文獻綜合研究集刊. 11. 巴蜀書社.
- 李瑾, 〈殷代甲骨刻辞中“夔方”地理释证〉, 《人文杂志》1959年第4期, pp.71–77
- Wang 王, Ning 寧 (2012). "古籍著錄的兩件商彝銘文校釋". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心.
- 㠱 in 漢語多功能字庫. The Chinese University of Hong Kong, 2026. https://humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=%E3%A0%B1
- Yang 杨, Yang 杨 (2018). ""大隐于朝"展陈龟腹甲的再整理" (PDF). 故宫学刊. 19.
- 盧 in 漢語多功能字庫. The Chinese University of Hong Kong, 2026. https://humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=%E7%9B%A7
- "亞醜者姤方尊". 故宮博物院. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- "不". 漢字甲骨部件分析 (in Chinese). Chinese University of Hong Kong. 2014. Retrieved 21 April 2026.
四,國名,典籍作「邳」。邳伯罍:「不(邳)白(伯)夏子自乍阝尊罍」。
- "文物志(1991—2005),第二编 可移动文物, 第三章 铜器 铁器 金银器, 第一节 铜 器". 山东地情档案. 山东地方志资料归档. 1991–2005. Retrieved 21 April 2026.
邳伯罍 春秋。共2件,形制相同。高28.5厘米,口径21.3厘米,腹径36厘米。口沿外卷,束颈,斜肩,折腹,双兽首衔环形耳。器身饰蟠虺纹。口沿铸有铭文"隹正月初吉,丁亥,邳伯夏子自作尊罍,用祈眉寿无疆,子子孙孙永宝用之"。1954年峄县文化馆征集。藏于山东省博物馆。
- 方稚松:〈小臣墙骨版刻辞残缺文字拟补〉,《故宮博物院院刊》2019年第2期,第202期,頁40–48.
- 張秉權:〈卜辭中所見殷商政治統一的力量及其達到的範圍〉,《中央研究院歷史語言研究所集刊》第50本第1分,1979年3月,頁175–229.
- 張, 秉權 (1979). "卜辭中所見殷商政治統一的力量及其達到的範圍" [The Power and Scope of the Political Unification of the Shang Dynasty as Observed in the Oracle Bone Inscriptions]. 中央研究院歷史語言研究所集刊. 50 (1): 175–229.
- "從甲骨卜辭論殷商時期的「倉」國". 每日頭條. 中國倉頡文化傳習中心. 2019. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 王立新. 2025. 商王朝国家形式的考古学观察. 《中国社会科学》2025年第10期P187—P203
- 滕興建〈武丁時期伐缶方戰役的時間排譜〉, 《殷都學刊》2018年第2期, pp.12–18
- 丹 in 漢語多功能字庫, The Chinese University of Hong Kong. 2026. https://humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=丹
- 光 in 漢語多功能字庫, The Chinese University of Hong Kong. 2026. https://humanum.arts.cuhk.edu.hk/Lexis/lexi-mf/search.php?word=光
- Wang 王, Entian 恩田 (2015). "呂方考". 复旦大学出土文献与古文字研究中心. Retrieved 2 June 2026.
- 胡厚宣.卜辞中所见之殷代农业.台湾大通书局,1972年:52
- 韩江苏 江林昌 等.《中国商代史第二卷》.中国社会科学出版社,2006:478-482
- Zhang 张, Liejun 利军 (24 September 2023). 张利军:殷卜辞所见外服“侯”考(上)_腾讯新闻 (in Chinese (China)) (QQ ed, originally published in 《中国历史研究院集刊》2022年第2期 ed.). 中国历史研究院. Retrieved 25 May 2026.
- Takashima, Kenichi (2011). "Literacy to the South and East of Anyang". In Feng, Li; Banner, David Prager (eds.). Writing & literacy in early China: studies from the Columbia Early China Seminar. Seattle: University of Washington press. pp. 151–155. ISBN 9780295991528.